Aaron Spencer- Hero or Murderer

Aaron Spencer- Hero or Murderer In this Bloodlines and Betrayal episode, hosts David Schuman and Steve Cully tackle the haunting case of Aaron Spencer — a man caught between the labels of hero and murderer. What began as an act of courage soon spiraled into controversy, forcing a nation to question where justice ends and vengeance begins.

Schuman and Cully trace the events leading up to the fateful night that left one man dead and Spencer standing over the body. To some, he was defending himself and others — a symbol of bravery under fire. To others, he was a man who crossed the line, taking the law into his own hands.

Through witness accounts, courtroom testimony, and media spin, the hosts explore how truth can fracture under pressure, turning facts into weapons and reputation into ruin. They examine whether Spencer’s actions were born from fear, duty, or something darker — and how society’s rush to judgment can make a villain of a savior.

Ultimately, Bloodlines and Betrayal leaves listeners with a chilling question: Was Aaron Spencer a man fighting for what’s right — or a killer who convinced himself he was?